If you grew up listening to Aerosmith, Led Zeppelin, Nirvana, or Weezer, you might picture a true guitar player with an electric guitar in hand, rocking out with powerful riffs and high-energy performances. But if your style leans more toward indie rock, campfire classics, or the timeless tunes of Johnny Cash or Joni Mitchell, an acoustic guitar might feel like a better fit.
Choosing between an acoustic and electric guitar isn’t just about following in the footsteps of your favorite rock stars or folk legends—it’s about discovering the instrument that feels like your perfect match. Whether you’re dreaming of shredding face-melting solos or strumming soulful ballads by the campfire, we’ve got you covered. Let’s dive into the pros and cons of both, so you can decide which guitar will make your musical journey truly rock (or roll, or strum…).
Acoustic Guitar
For many new to guitar playing, it seems that the acoustic guitar is the first choice. We’re not saying that this should necessarily be the case but let’s investigate it. Acoustic guitars are complete, requiring no additional equipment to function. Acoustic guitars are self-sufficient: they create their own sound and require no additional equipment in order to fully function. No amp, no cables, no electricity. This certainly makes acoustic guitar playing simple. Just pick it up and you play it!
Electric Guitar
But what if you love Rock guitar riffs? Wild sounds? Metal? All the above are more achievable with an electric guitar. They are easier to play because of their slim bodies, thinner necks and the strings are much less rigid. That makes electric guitars far more ergonomic.
Most people don’t realize it, but you can hear an unplugged electric guitar. It just doesn’t sound like what you’re expecting. Having an amp and a guitar cable will bring that sound to the next level but won’t deliver the classic vibe you’re looking to achieve. These add to the cost of purchasing or renting an electric guitar, but we do have these items in stock at some great prices!
Don’t Limit Yourself When Making a Choice
While genres that come to mind when thinking about these guitars, don’t let these initial thoughts drive your decision. Both options are versatile and can help you explore new musical styles. For a little inspiration, here is a list of some excellent options for both acoustic and electric guitars.
Acoustic Genres
- Acoustic Blues
- Campfire Favorites (that’s my term)
- Country and Bluegrass
- Folk
- Indie Rock
- New Age
Electric Genres
- Alternative Rock
- Blues
- Funk
- Hard Rock
- Jazz
- Metal
- Punk
- Pop
- Reggae
- Rock
These are just a few examples. There are many more genres to explore. Plus, many artists blend styles, creating unique crossover genres that push the boundaries of traditional music categories.
Which is Easier for Beginners?
There is no right answer when choosing between an acoustic or electric guitar. All guitars are played the same way, but they aren’t the same. While some people suggest starting with an acoustic guitar and moving to electric later, it’s better to consider all the factors before deciding.
For beginners, factors like string type and neck shape can make one guitar easier to play than another. Nylon-stringed acoustics are gentler on the fingers, while electric guitars often have narrower necks for easier picking, and steel-stringed acoustics present more of a challenge. Neck shapes (C-shaped for small/average hands, U-shaped for larger hands) also impact comfort.
Which Do I Pick?
Your best bet is to choose based on your music preference, patience and motivation. If you like the genres for an acoustic guitar, then go for it. On the flipside, if you want to play rock songs, and you’re okay with a little challenge and initial discomfort give your hands and fingers an easier time of it, then electric guitars will be a better choice for you. Ultimately, choose the one that aligns with your musical goals and comfort level.
Where Do I Start?
The best way to start your search is a hands-on approach. Stop by the shop and pick up a guitar. Get the feel of it. Strum its strings and see which option speaks to you. Then, work with us to choose the best instructor for your choice.
Some instructors stick to teaching the option they love, whether its acoustic or electric, simply because that is where their passion lies. Others choose to be more versatile because they have a strong appreciation for both and are driven more by just helping students pursue their own passion, no matter what their choice.
Take the First Step
We have so many great instructors and can easily match you up with the perfect fit for you. Contact us today at (330) 342-7317 or sean@westernreservemusic.com to get started, or stop by the shop.
